• 02046348617
Home Articles Broker vs Going Direct to the Lender: The Honest Maths

Broker vs Going Direct to the Lender: The Honest Maths

November 16, 2026 9 Min Read
Broker Selection
Broker vs Going Direct to the Lender: The Honest Maths

✅ Is it better to use a broker or go direct to a lender?

For most commercial and specialist property borrowing, a broker gives the better result, but not always. The broker vs going direct to lender question comes down to four things: choice, cost, time and risk. Going direct gives you one lender's view and one lender's price. A broker compares many, including lenders that do not deal with the public at all. Where the broker is paid by the lender and charges you nothing, you get that comparison at no extra cost. Going direct can make sense if you have a strong relationship with your bank, a simple request and an offer you have already checked against the market, or where a lender only accepts direct applications. The honest answer is to do both: get your bank's terms, then ask a broker whether the market can beat them. Money Pilot compares 200+ lenders with zero broker fees, FCA regulated (FRN: 968705).

The broker vs going direct to lender decision comes up every time rates move, and they have just moved again, with Bank Rate rising to 4% in November. Borrowers reasonably ask whether a middleman adds cost. Sometimes one does. This guide sets out the arithmetic without a sales pitch: what each route costs, what it gives you and where going direct is the sensible choice.

Bank of England interest rate hold 4.25% UK SME business impact June 2026

Bank of England held base rate at 4.25% in June 2026 - waiting for inflation to cool.

UK SME business confidence growth AI technology adoption 2026

73% of UK SMEs expect to grow in the next 12 months - confidence remains strong.

Is a broker cheaper than direct? A worked comparison

The question, is a broker cheaper than direct, can be answered only by comparing the total cost of the loan, not the headline rate or the fee alone. The example below is illustrative: a £500,000 commercial mortgage over five years.

Direct to your bankBroker with a 1% feeBroker with no client fee
Rate obtained7.25%6.75%6.75%
Lender arrangement fee1.5% (£7,500)1.5% (£7,500)1.5% (£7,500)
Broker feeNone£5,000None
Interest over five years, interest only basis£181,250£168,750£168,750
Total cost over five years£188,750£181,250£176,250

In this example a half point saving is worth £12,500 over the term, which outweighs a 1% broker fee and is better still where no fee is charged. The result reverses if the broker cannot improve on the bank's rate. That is the point: the value depends on the gap between the first offer and the best available one. Rates shown are for illustration and will differ for your case.

Brokers who charge no client fee are paid a commission by the lender on completion. Ask for the figure. It is a fair question, and the answer should be given in writing. Our guide to what broker fees are acceptable explains the usual ranges.

Direct only lenders: UK list of categories, and its limits

People often search for a direct only lenders uk list. No reliable public list exists, because lenders change their distribution regularly. It is more useful to know the categories.

  • Your own bank's relationship team. High street banks lend to existing business customers directly, and some pricing is reserved for those relationships.
  • Some building societies and smaller banks. A few accept commercial enquiries only from local or existing customers.
  • Government backed and community lenders. Some regional funds and responsible finance providers take applications directly.
  • Online lenders for small loans. Many unsecured business loan providers have direct application journeys, though most also work with brokers.
  • Broker only lenders. The reverse case, and a large one. Many specialist bridging, development and buy to let lenders do not accept applications from the public at all.

A good broker will tell you when a direct only option is likely to be your best route, even though they earn nothing from it. Ask the question outright.

Broker added value: evidence to look for

Broker added value evidence should be specific to your case, not a general claim. Ask a broker to show you:

What to request:

  • The comparison: which lenders were considered, on what terms, and why the recommendation was chosen
  • Total cost: rate, all fees and exit charges set side by side
  • Criteria fit: confirmation the lender accepts your property type, trading history and structure
  • Access: whether the lender or product is available only through intermediaries
  • Time saved: who prepares the application, chases the valuer and manages the solicitors
  • A second route: what happens if the first lender declines

When going direct is the right call

Going direct is reasonable where your bank knows the business well, the request is simple, and the terms offered are competitive when checked. It may also be quicker for a small increase on an existing facility. It is weaker where the case has any complexity: a new venture, mixed use property, limited accounts, a tight deadline or a previous decline. In those cases a single refusal costs time and can leave a record of the search.

Capital rules matter too. With Basel 3.1 taking effect in the UK from January 2027, banks are reassessing how much capital some loans require, which may widen differences in pricing between lenders. Our guide to Basel 3.1 and UK business lending explains why. For more on selection, see questions to ask a commercial finance broker and what whole of market means. If you already have a bank offer for a commercial mortgage, business finance or bridging finance, send it to us. We will check it against 200+ lenders and tell you plainly if it is the best you will get, with zero broker fees.

What does Money Pilot do?

Our smart-search engine analyses your requirements — amount, term, business type, and credit profile — then instantly matches them against our panel of 200+ lenders.

Got Questions?

Frequently asked questions.

Everything you need to know about comparing finance and using Money Pilot. Can't find an answer?

Talk to our team
Do brokers get better rates than going direct?

Often, but not always. Brokers can access lenders and products that are not offered to the public, and they compare many lenders. If your own bank's offer is already the best available, a good broker will say so.

It depends on how the broker is paid. Some charge a fee to the client, usually on completion. Others are paid only by the lender. Compare the total cost of the loan including all fees, not just the rate.

Yes, and it is sensible. Tell the broker which lenders you have already approached so they do not duplicate the application, which could cause confusion or repeated credit searches.

Yes. Many specialist bridging, development, buy to let and commercial lenders accept applications only from intermediaries, because brokers package cases in the form the lender needs.

Usually the reverse. A broker who knows each lender's criteria and documents can avoid declined applications and repeated requests for information, which are the main causes of delay.

We compare your case, or an offer you already hold, across 200+ lenders and explain the result in writing. We charge zero broker fees and are FCA regulated (FRN: 968705).

Still have questions?

Our team typically replies within 2 hours.

Send us a message

How Does It Work?

Three simple steps to get you the funding you need, faster.

1
Submit Enquiry

Complete a fast but in-depth overview of your finance requirements to allow our powerful matching engine to source the right lenders for you.

2
Connect

Engage directly with lenders in real-time, with our friendly advisors always on hand to guide you through every step of the funding journey.

3
Apply

Track your enquiry in real-time and seamlessly move to application — all in one place — getting you to your funds faster and with less hassle.

Get in touch with our team

Get a Quick Quote

Get in touch with our team

Contact Us

Telephone: 02046348617

Email: info@money-pilot.co.uk

Unit 1, Verney House
1B Hollywood Road, London
SW10 9HS

Opening Times: 9am - 6pm, Mon - Fri

Company Registration No.
13621432